Andrew Alvarez is about to walk into a buzzsaw, and the Nationals don’t even seem to know it yet. The left-hander’s 3.17 ERA looks perfectly respectable on paper—the kind of number that keeps you employed in September—but it’s masking something uglier: he’s been getting shelled by quality lineups all year, and the Mets are bringing exactly that kind of lineup to Nationals Park tonight. Juan Soto alone should make Alvarez nervous. The man is hitting .274 with a .915 OPS in 108 games, which means he’s been one of the three or four most consistent run-creators in baseball for two months straight. That’s not a hot streak anymore. That’s a player locked in.
The real problem for Alvarez is that Soto doesn’t stand alone. Carson Benge has quietly accumulated 22 stolen bases and a .757 OPS in a full season of work, which translates to a guy who creates problems just by existing in the batter’s box. He’s the kind of runner who makes pitchers rush, and Alvarez—a 1.26 WHIP guy who needs precision—is exactly the type of starter who can’t afford to get accelerated. When a pitcher gets uncomfortable, his command fragments. When his command fragments against a lineup this talented, bad things follow fast.
New York Mets Players to Watch
Juan Soto’s .915 OPS represents the top tier of offensive productivity, but what matters tonight is how that translates specifically against a left-handed starter. Alvarez has given up his share of hard contact to opposite-handed hitters—the kind of elevated fastballs that Soto punishes. Look for Soto to get to at least one run tonight; he’s in the kind of form where you’re backing him in almost any matchup, and this one has a mismatch flavor to it.
Carson Benge’s 22 stolen bases are the quiet story here. Alvarez has a 1.42 seconds-to-plate time—nothing alarming, but not lightning-quick either—and Benge has proven he’ll run on anyone this year. The stolen base prop on Benge should draw your attention, particularly if the Nationals’ catcher isn’t having a particularly sharp night throwing out runners. Benge’s aggressive baserunning has become a consistent part of the Mets’ offensive engine in September.
Washington Nationals Players to Watch
James Wood represents the Nationals’ best hope to keep pace offensively. His .890 OPS and 30 home runs mark him as a legitimate middle-of-the-order threat, and against a Mets pitcher who hasn’t been identified yet, Wood’s power could matter. The 21 stolen bases are a bonus—another runner who isn’t afraid to take an extra base when the opportunity presents itself.
Yohandy Morales is a curveball here: just 15 games played, but a .930 OPS that screams opportunity. If he’s in the lineup against a right-handed starter, Morales’ elite on-base skills could create an interesting runs-scored prop, particularly if he can get on base early and let Wood drive him in. The sample is small, but the OPS suggests the Nationals might have found something real.
PropsBot AI Picks for New York Mets vs. Washington Nationals
This is the kind of game where identifying the specific edges matters more than usual. The Mets have the offensive firepower advantage, Alvarez is vulnerable to quality contact, and both lineups feature runners who will test the Nationals’ ability to control the running game. Rather than guessing, head to PropsBot and let their AI-driven picks surface the exact edges that matter—the ones that have historically delivered 31.7% ROI across MLB props. Visit app.propsbot.ai to build your slate for tonight and find the angles hiding in plain sight.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best player prop bets for New York Mets vs. Washington Nationals?
Juan Soto’s runs-scored prop deserves attention given his consistency and the matchup against Alvarez; Carson Benge’s stolen bases projection is worth tracking if the line accounts for his aggressive September; and James Wood’s home run total could offer value if oddsmakers underestimate his power against a Mets staff that hasn’t been dominant late in the season.
What time does New York Mets vs. Washington Nationals start on September 25, 2026?
Game time for this matchup has not been officially announced as of publication, but September day games at Nationals Park typically start at 1:05 PM ET. Check MLB.com or your sportsbook closer to game time for the official start.
Get every AI pick, Confidence Score, and prop edge inside the app.
See Today’s AI Picks